
How to Calculate AP Automation ROI (With a Framework)
by Hannah Khouri
Today, the term “ROI” gets thrown around pretty loosely in conversations about AP automation. But vague promises of time savings, less manual work, and fewer errors aren’t enough to secure buy-in. Instead, teams must build a strong business case with ROI projects that’ll stand up to scrutiny.
Calculating AP automation ROI starts with understanding the current cost of manual invoice processing, then comparing that to the expected cost after investing in AP automation. From there, finance leaders can calculate a defensible payback period and factor in benefits that are more difficult to quantify, such as a lower risk of fraud and more captured early-payment discounts.
The following four-step framework can help you build a defensible accounts payable automation business case. It walks you through the inputs and calculations you need to estimate AP automation ROI and determine how long it’ll take to recoup your initial investment.
Step 1: Establish your current cost per invoice
The first step of calculating AP automation ROI is determining how much your business currently spends processing invoices. Your cost per invoice, which is the total cost of processing an invoice from receipt to payment, is a good place to start. It’s important to consider the cost of routine processing, as well as the cost of addressing errors and rework.
Labor cost of routine processing
First, factor in routine labor costs. Estimate how many hours your AP team spends processing invoices based on team tracking data. Include the time spent on all routine tasks, including:
- Receiving invoices
- Entering and coding data
- Matching invoices to purchase orders and receipts
- Securing approvals
- Preparing payments
Then, multiply those hours by the total hourly cost of the employees doing the work. Be sure to use the fully loaded hourly cost, which includes salary, payroll taxes, and benefits.
Annual AP labor cost = Annual hours spent processing invoices × Fully loaded hourly labor cost
Divide that figure by your annual invoice volume to determine your baseline labor cost per invoice.
Cost of errors and rework
It’s also important to factor in the cost of handling exceptions, coding errors, duplicate invoices, and payment corrections. Consult past audit findings, payment records, and AP team time-tracking data to determine how often these issues occur and how much time your team spends resolving them.
Multiply the number of hours spent on errors and rework by the fully loaded hourly cost of the employees handling that work.
Adding these costs to your baseline will give you a more complete picture of what manual invoice processing actually costs your business. Divide this figure by your annual invoice volume to determine the total average cost of processing an invoice.
Step 2: Estimate your automation-adjusted cost per invoice
Once you have a realistic picture of your current cost per invoice, estimate what it’ll be after implementing an AP automation solution. Use the same categories from step 1 so you have a direct comparison between your current and projected costs.
Projected labor cost with AP automation
Estimate how much hands-on processing time will be eliminated with AP automation. Any AP automation vendors you’re speaking with should be able to provide expected processing time reductions. Make sure those projections are based on your actual invoice volume, workflows, and level of automation, not generic inputs.
Subtract that projected reduction from the annual processing hours you calculated in step 1, then multiply the remaining hours by your fully loaded hourly labor cost. That’ll give you your projected annual AP labor cost.
Projected errors and rework cost with AP automation
No AP automation solution will completely eliminate every error and exception. But the best ones will definitely reduce them.
Estimate the percentage of invoices that will still require manual review, along with the average amount of time needed to resolve them. Base this on results from organizations with similar invoice volumes and workflows, which your AP vendor should be able to provide. Remember: broad averages won’t give you a true picture of what you can expect.
Add your projected routine processing and rework costs together, then divide by your annual invoice volume to calculate your estimated cost per invoice after implementing AP automation.
AP automation costs
When calculating AP automation ROI, it’s also important to factor in the cost of the AP automation solution itself. Separate recurring software or transaction fees from one-time implementation and onboarding costs.
Keep those one-time costs separate from your automation-adjusted cost per invoice. You’ll use them in step 3 to determine your estimated payback period.
Step 3: Calculate AP automation ROI and payback period
Once you’ve determined your current and projected costs, you can calculate the expected return on investment.
Start by determining your annual savings. Subtract your projected annual processing costs, including recurring software costs, from what you currently spend processing invoices.
For example, consider a fictitious multi-location hospitality company that currently spends $120,000 each year manually processing invoices. After implementing an AP automation solution, it expects to pay $70,000 per year on AP labor, error and rework costs, and recurring software expenses. This amounts to an annual cost savings of $50,000.
Next, you can calculate AP automation ROI by subtracting your upfront implementation cost from your annual savings, then dividing that figure by your upfront implementation cost. Multiple that figure by 100 to get your first-year ROI percentage.
Here’s what that calculation looks like for the same fictitious company if their implementation and onboarding costs total $20,000.
You can also calculate the AP automation payback period, which is the amount of time it will take for the savings from AP automation to make up for your upfront investment. To do this, divide your annual savings by 12 to determine your average monthly savings. Then, divide your upfront implementation cost by that amount.
In the same example, $50,000 in annual savings amounts to approximately $4,167 in monthly savings. When the upfront implementation cost of $20,000 is divided by the $4,167 in monthly savings, the result is an AP automation payback period of 4.8 months.
Step 4: Factor in other financial benefits
Labor savings is a useful starting point for calculating AP automation ROI. But it doesn’t capture the full story of financial impact. AP automation can also provide other financial benefits that are important, but more difficult to predict. Some examples include fewer duplicate and fraudulent payments, more captured early-payment discounts, and less time spent on audits and month-end close.
Vague promises of greater efficiency across these areas won’t work. Whenever possible, calculate these financial benefits separately based on your organization’s historical data.
Reduction in duplicate payments and fraud
AP automation can detect duplicate invoices and suspicious activity that would otherwise be missed. When teams are aware of issues, they can take action to prevent financial loss.
To estimate the potential financial impact, review your historical payment and audit data to see how much your organization has lost to duplicate payments, overpayments, or fraud during a set period of time. Estimate the portion of those losses that an AP automation platform would reasonably be expected to identify and prevent.
Increase in early-payment discounts
AP automation can help finance teams process invoices faster, which gives them more opportunities to capture early-payment discounts.
Review your data to determine how often you’ve missed out on early-payment discounts, as well as the total value. Then, estimate how many of those discounts your organization could realistically capture if your processing cycle was shorter.
Less time on audits and month-end close
Manual processes can add hours to audits and the monthly AP close. AP automation can reduce the amount of finance team time required for both.
Estimate how many hours your team currently spends on AP-related audit preparation, reconciliation, and month-end close. Then, estimate how much that number would go down after implementing AP automation. Multiply the reduction in hours with your team’s fully loaded labor cost to get an estimate of the financial impact.
Keep these benefits separate from your core labor-savings calculation. This will make it easier to show which parts of your AP automation ROI estimate are based on predictable processing savings and which depend on additional assumptions.
What this AP automation ROI framework doesn’t capture
Company leaders need hard numbers to justify investments, so a strong accounts payable automation business case should be grounded in quantifiable benefits. That said, AP automation can also deliver benefits that are more difficult to quantify. While they do matter, they aren’t captured in this framework.
For example, AP automation can decrease the amount of repetitive manual work AP teams must manage, which frees them up to focus on more fulfilling work. That shift can increase employee satisfaction, which makes it easier for finance leaders to retain experienced staff. While this certainly matters, the impact can be difficult to quantify in an ROI calculation.
Scalability is another benefit that’s difficult to assign a dollar figure to. Typically, businesses that manually process invoices must add AP headcount when they expand to new locations or see an uptick in invoice volume. AP automation can open up capacity so the same number of employees can process a higher volume of invoices. But unless you have a specific hiring plan that would be eliminated or delayed because of AP automation, those savings are tricky to quantify.
Soft benefits still belong in conversations about the impact of AP automation. But your projected ROI should be based primarily on costs and savings that you can back up with your own financial and operational data.
FAQ
Build a defensible business case for AP automation
Calculating AP automation ROI gives finance leaders the hard numbers needed to understand impact. By starting with your own processing costs and using realistic assumptions about future savings, you’ll build a defensible accounts payable automation business case that builds internal buy-in and secures investments.
Want to see Ottimate in action?
Curious to see how AI-powered AP automation drives ROI for multi-location businesses like Torchy’s Tacos?